Why Commute Distance Matters When Hiring Restaurant Staff

Commute distance when hiring gets overlooked because it doesn’t appear on a resume. It affects whether a new employee can work the schedule you hired them for. Restaurants keep odd hours, and public transit doesn’t run the same way at 1 a.m. or 5 a.m. as it does at noon. That goes double for restaurants hiring in New York City, where a lot of staff get to work on subways and buses.

A commute that looks fine on paper can turn into late arrivals and early turnover once the real schedule kicks in. Checking it during hiring takes a few minutes. This article covers when a commute becomes a real problem and how to ask about it without ruling out good candidates.

How Commutes Affect Restaurant Staffing

Nobody quits over one rough commute. It builds. The first few late trains home are fine. Then the delays pile up, the fares add up, and getting home at 1 a.m. starts to feel like a part of the job nobody mentioned. The restaurant feels it too. One person runs late and the opener is stuck doing prep alone. The closing crew stands around waiting on a replacement. Left alone, that strain is one of the quieter reasons why restaurant employees quit.

Commute and employee turnover go hand in hand. Take a four-hour shift that comes with two hours of travel. The math stops working, especially for hourly staff weighing fares against what they take home. Catch that during hiring and you can fix the schedule before it costs you someone. That’s a big part of restaurant staff retention.

When Commute Distance Becomes a Problem

How much a commute matters depends on the shift. These are the ones that cause the most trouble:

• Late closes: Transit thins out after midnight, so the trip home takes longer.
• Early prep: Some lines don’t run often enough before sunrise to get someone in on time.
• Split shifts: Two round trips in one day is a lot to ask.
• Short shifts: With a long trip and a short shift, fares eat the pay.
• Bad weather: Snow and storms slow everything down, and a long route gets longer.
• Last-minute coverage: Someone with a long or shaky route can’t say yes to a same-day shift.

Keep these in mind when you set candidate availability for the role, and put the shift times in the posting so people know up front.

Distance Isn't the Deciding Factor 

Two applicants living five miles from the same restaurant can have completely different commutes. One has a direct subway connection, while the other needs two transfers and a bus that runs less frequently after dinner service. A ZIP code won’t reveal that difference, and automatically favoring the closer applicant could mean passing over someone with stronger qualifications and a perfectly workable commute.

For a kitchen management role, a candidate traveling from another borough with experience running a high-volume kitchen may be worth the longer journey. For a part-time server working four-hour shifts, living nearby could make the job more practical. Commute distance when hiring should carry more weight when the hours or demands of the position make transportation a genuine concern.

How to Assess Commute Reliability

Ask about the commute early, during restaurant candidate screening, especially for closing and opening shifts. Tell candidates the exact start and end times first, then ask if they can make those times consistently.

Useful questions include:

• Can the applicant arrive for a 6 a.m. prep shift or leave after a midnight closing?
• Are there recurring transportation limitations that affect the required hours?
• Can the applicant work the assigned schedule, including weekends?
• Would occasional changes to shift start or end times create difficulties?
• Is the proposed schedule realistic for the applicant on an ongoing basis?

Keep the questions on the schedule. Skip where they live and how they get around.

When the Candidate Is Worth Adjusting the Schedule

A strong applicant shouldn’t automatically be ruled out because the last train home leaves before closing. Sometimes a small scheduling change is enough. A restaurant might assign an experienced cook to earlier shifts, adjust a start time around transit availability, or reserve late closes for employees who can consistently work them. Small adjustments like these are one reason better scheduling improves restaurant employee retention.

Of course, not every schedule has room to move. A restaurant still needs people who can open on time and stay through closing. The question is whether the candidate’s experience justifies some flexibility without leaving the rest of the team covering inconvenient hours. If the adjustment creates more staffing problems than it solves, the position probably isn’t the right fit.

Make Commute Part of Screening

Commute information is only useful when managers can compare it against the position’s actual requirements. For restaurants hiring across multiple locations, a candidate may be able to work closing shifts at one location but not another. Recording those restrictions alongside availability makes it easier to identify which openings are realistic before arranging interviews.

OneTeam’s AI candidate screening considers proximity alongside experience and availability, helping managers identify applicants worth reviewing. Distance can inform the shortlist, but the candidate’s ability to work the required hours still needs to be confirmed.

Hire for Long-Term Reliability

A vacant position may be filled in a week, but the consequences of a poor hiring decision can last much longer. When transportation difficulties begin affecting attendance or shift coverage, managers are left adjusting schedules, asking existing employees to cover gaps, or restarting recruitment.

One Team´s AI hiring software helps restaurants consider proximity alongside other hiring requirements before narrowing down applicants. Build a shortlist around the realities of the position, so the next hire fills the gap and the schedule holds.

‍